When it comes to pickleball paddles, there’s more hype than substance.
Between flashy marketing, glowing YouTube reviews, and paddle companies making big promises, most players are left thinking they need the latest, high-tech paddle to perform well.
But, here’s the truth…You absolutely don’t!
The list of 3 priorities I’m about to describe, provide beginner to intermediate players with all of the capabilities needed to support their skill development.
And this isn’t simply a theory of mine.
Seasoned players and coaches will tell you it’s all about mastering the fundamentals, not chasing the newest paddle trends.
What’s more, is that a number of paddle brand reps have also confirmed how these three product features are the most ideal set up for beginner and intermediate players.
Let’s dive into what you really need to know about choosing the right pickleball paddle.
Watch my breakdown of these 3 key factors:
Make sure to also check our guide on 14mm vs. 16mm pickleball paddles.
The 3 Key Paddle Features That Matter
For beginner and intermediate players, here are the only three things that really matter:
- 16mm Thick Paddle: Thicker paddles offer more control, making them ideal for those still refining their game.
- Elongated Shape: This form factor gives you extra reach, which can help you cover the court more efficiently.
- Carbon Fiber Face: The textured surface of carbon fiber allows for better spin and more accurate ball control.
Plus, 50 paddles in our paddle database meet these criteria, with 30 priced under $180.
Paddle companies would have you believe that spending more gets you a “better” paddle, but for most players, these features are all you need.
What Pickleball Players Value in a Paddle
1. “It’s about control, not power.”
Many experienced players say that control should be prioritized over power, especially if you’re new to the game.
Not convinced, here’s Pro/Coach William East noting this exact point.
Additionally, a longer paddle helps you reach balls more easily, and thicker cores make the paddle more forgiving, meaning you’ll hit more balls in play rather than sending them out of bounds.
2. “Find what works for your game, not the most expensive paddle.”
Players also emphasize finding a paddle that supports your personal style and skill development goals, rather than going after the latest trends. One player said, “I went through about 20 paddles, and honestly, they all felt the same—until I finally found one that gave me the control I was looking for.”
The lesson? Demo different paddles if possible and pick the one that suits your style—whether it’s priced at $30 or $300.
Be sure to check out our guide on how to demo pickleball paddles for free!
How Paddle Brands Mislead You
The reality is that many paddle brands get their paddles manufactured in the same factory and slap on their logos, meaning there’s little difference between them besides branding.
As one seasoned player put it, “Out of the box, most paddles are practically indistinguishable.” In other words, don’t be fooled by high prices or overblown marketing.
Paddle Performance vs. Player Performance
As the saying goes, “It’s the player, not the paddle.” Many high-level players argue that a paddle’s features won’t compensate for poor technique or bad footwork.
If you’re new to the game, focus on improving your skills rather than upgrading to the most expensive paddle on the market.
My Favorite Paddle That Checks These Boxes
In early 2024, Franklin announced their FS Tour line of paddles, which has become a very smart expansion of their paddle lineup.
The FS Tour Dynasty 16mm meets all the priorities listed above and I’ve had it in my bag for over 6 months now. Here’s our full review if you want to learn more.
We give this model a green light for beginner to intermediate players looking for more touch and control. Or trade a bit of control for more power, with the 14mm model.
Plus, Franklin’s FS Tour line included other options, like the 14mm Dynasty and the Tempo in both 16mm and 14mm.
5 Paddle-Picking Tips from Pickleball Pros
Here’s what some seasoned pickleball players have to say about choosing paddles:
- Forget the Hype: “Your paddle isn’t nearly as important as your technique. I’ve used $30 paddles and still managed to beat players with $200 ones.”
- Thicker is Better for Beginners: “Beginners do better with more forgiving paddles. A thicker core helps keep the ball in play and makes the game easier to manage.”
- Buy What Fits Your Game: “It’s all about finding the right fit for your game. Personally, a paddle with less power but better control made a world of difference for me.”
- Be Wary of Brand Promises: “Most companies are selling the same paddles with different designs slapped on. Instead of getting caught up in brands, focus on the paddle’s specs and what fits your game.”
- Don’t Upgrade Until You Need To: “Keep using your current paddle until you’re consistently winning matches. Most of the time, it’s your technique that needs work, not the gear.”
Stick to the Essentials
So, do you really need an expensive pickleball paddle? Not at all.
Focus on the basics:
- A 16mm thick paddle for control
- An elongated shape for extra reach
- A carbon fiber face for better ball control
For the majority of players, these features will help improve your game more than any advanced tech a brand promises. And remember—practice and good mechanics will always outperform fancy paddles.
